American ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican Express
United StatesChange Country

7 Factors to Consider When Comparing Credit Cards

Compare the wide range of credit cards and choose the one that suits you best. There are 7 key factors to consider before you apply for one.

By Megan Doyle | American Express Credit Intel Freelance Contributor

5 Min Read | November 30, 2020 in Cards



Comparing credit cards can feel overwhelming because there are so many of them, and they have a wide range of different characteristics.

But a careful analysis of several factors, including credit card rewards, fees, interest rates – and your unique personal finance needs – can help you choose.

If you ever seriously try to compare credit cards, you might notice how much it’s like navigating the cereal aisle at the grocery store. The abundance of possibilities is alluring, but if you really try to make an informed, analytical choice, you could become a victim of “analysis paralysis.” 


It doesn’t have to be that way. To help make your credit card comparison a little bit easier, here are seven key factors to consider. (You’re on your own with the cereal.)


1. Understand Your Financial Profile and Spending Habits

Before you start comparing credit cards, it’s best to understand your own financial profile. Your credit score and credit history play a big role in what type of credit card you can get. Most high-end credit cards are typically reserved for those with excellent credit, though there are plenty of cards available for those simply looking to establish their credit history, too. 


It also helps to know your spending habits. Remember that a credit card isn’t a source of free money – you have to pay back every purchase, and any unpaid monthly balance will likely start to collect interest.


2. Ask Yourself: Why Do I Want a Credit Card?

Whether you’re getting your first card or adding to a collection, ask yourself why you want a credit card. Your answer will be the basis for determining which credit cards to compare and, ultimately, which one to choose. Here are a few reasons you might want a credit card and some matching card types:

  • If you’re an avid traveler, look into cards that offer hotel, airline, or general travel rewards.
  • If you’re a small business owner, a cash back business credit card can help you pay for company expenses.
  • If you’re just starting to build credit, consider a card with no annual fees and a low APR.
  • If you want to make a balance transfer, compare credit cards that offer no-fee balance transfers or 0% balance transfers.


3. Compare Credit Card Rewards

One of the biggest benefits to having a credit card is that many offer rewards for purchases you’re already making. Some cards offer a percentage of purchase spending as cash back, redeemable for statement credit, while others offer points or travel miles for every dollar you spend. If you compare basic points or cash back credit cards, you’ll usually find low or no annual fee credit cards that offer a small percent – 1 or 1.5 – of cash back rewards or points for purchases in any spending category. On the other side of the spectrum are specialized cards with higher fees that offer higher rewards for specific spending categories, like travel, dining, entertainment, groceries, and more. 


Understanding how you plan to use your card will help you choose the best one for you. For example, hotel or airline credit cards might not make much sense if you rarely fly, and you probably wouldn’t want a gas credit card if you don’t own a car.


4. Compare Annual Fees

Another way to compare credit cards is by annual fee, which can range anywhere from none to upward of $450 for “elite” travel cards.1 Typically, cards with more lucrative rewards charge higher annual fees.2 But that doesn’t mean you can’t find a great rewards card with no annual fee. 


When it comes to annual fees, a good rule of thumb is to ensure that the value of the card’s rewards and benefits will make the fee worthwhile.3 If you’re an avid traveler with an airline card that gets you free checked bags, free airport lounge access, and priority boarding, the higher fee might be well worth it. But if you’re not going to use the card often or accrue rewards, take some time to consider whether the annual fee is worth the cost.


5. Compare Interest Rates

Credit cards can have a variety of different interest rates, aka APRs. APRs for purchases, balance transfers, and cash advances, for example, are usually all different. When comparing different credit cards’ APRs, the key thing to consider is whether you plan to pay off your statement balance in full every month. If you do, a card with a higher APR might be a fine choice. But if you think there’s a chance you might carry a revolving balance, you’ll want the card with the lowest APR available – even massive rewards typically won’t compensate for the interest accrued with a high APR. If you’re planning to make a large purchase and would like to pay it off over time, consider comparing 0% introductory APR credit cards.


6. Compare Additional Fees and Penalties

Along with APRs and annual fees, some common credit fees include balance transfer fees, cash advance fees, foreign transaction fees, late fees, returned payment fees, and many more. Whether you’ll have extra fees depends on how you use your credit card. For example, if you don’t plan to use cash advances or make any balance transfers, you could consider a card that charges extra for those services. Or, if you plan to do a lot of international traveling, a no foreign transaction fee credit card might be the way to go. 


7. Compare Extra Benefits

Many credit cards offer additional benefits like rental car insurance, airport lounge access, roadside assistance, and extended product warranties, to name a few. But it’s not uncommon for extra benefits to come with a higher annual fee. When comparing a credit card’s extra benefits, consider your needs. Free airport lounge access might sound tempting, but it might not be worth the potential annual fee unless you spend a lot of time in airports.


The Takeaway

Whether you’re getting your first credit card or looking for a new one, shopping around for credit cards can seem overwhelming. But carefully considering these seven key factors can help shape your thinking and make it much easier for you to compare credit cards.

Megan Doyle

Megan Doyle is a business technology writer and researcher whose work focuses on financial services and cross-cultural diversity and inclusion.


All Credit Intel content is written by freelance authors and commissioned and paid for by American Express. 

The material made available for you on this website, Credit Intel, is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal, tax or financial advice. If you have questions, please consult your own professional legal, tax and financial advisors.