Should You Cancel Unused Credit Cards or Keep Them?
6 Min Read | Last updated: July 23, 2026
This article contains general information and is not intended to provide information that is specific to American Express products and services. Similar products and services offered by different companies will have different features and you should always read about product details before acquiring any financial product.
Should you close unused credit cards or keep them open? Explore the pros and cons, plus how closing an account can affect your credit score.
At-A-Glance
- Since unused credit cards can increase your overall available credit and lengthen your credit history, keeping them open is often better for your scores.
- Still, there may be valid reasons to close an unused card, like overspending, high annual fees, or poor card issuer security.
- If you can safely keep your card open, you can set up autopay and link it to small recurring charges—or use it occasionally and pay it off quickly to help keep the account active and in good standing.
Closing a credit card you don’t use may seem like an obvious move. Maybe you cleaned out the junk drawer and discovered a forgotten credit card, which made you question whether it even needs to be open—especially if you want to simplify your finances or avoid annual fees and overspending. But before you cancel the card, it’s worth noting that a voluntary closure can still affect your credit. And understanding why may actually help improve your credit scores over time.
Should You Close Unused Credit Cards or Keep Them Open?
In many cases, it may make more sense to keep an unused credit card open and in good standing. That’s because an open card influences several of the five credit scoring factors.
Here’s how keeping the card open can benefit you:
- If you have a history of on-time payments for the card, that positively impacts the most important credit scoring factor: payment history.
- It adds to your total available credit, which may help lower your credit utilization ratio (how much of your credit is actively in use), the second most important scoring factor.1
- It can support a longer credit history (the third most important scoring factor)—especially for older accounts.2
- It can help diversify your credit mix (the fourth most important scoring factor), particularly if you already have different types of credit, such as car and student loans or a mortgage.3
Still, if the card comes with a high annual fee or makes it too easy to overspend, closing it might feel more manageable. And if the card is fairly new, closing it may have less impact on your history length, though losing that available credit could still push your utilization higher.
Is It Bad to Keep Credit Cards Open That I Never Use?
Keeping a little-used credit card open can actually be a practical move, given the benefits of payment history, utilization, account age, and credit mix discussed earlier. That said, some card issuers may close inactive accounts, which can create extra cleanup later if you need to remove closed accounts from your credit report. It may also be easier to miss suspicious charges or small recurring bills you forgot were attached to the card.
So if you do keep it open, it’s smart to check on it now and then.
Does Canceling a Credit Card Hurt Your Credit Score?
It can, but that doesn’t mean closing a card is always the wrong call. Sometimes, there are valid reasons to close an unused card:
- Expensive Annual Fees
You may be paying much more than the card gives back. - Overspending
Having extra credit available may make it harder to stick to your monthly budget. - The Card Was Just Opened
A newer, unused card isn’t going to alter your average credit age in the same way that a 15-year-old unused account would. - Security Concerns
Your card company may have experienced one, several, or ongoing security breaches, and you’re no longer able to depend on their fraud protections.
Alternatives to Closing Your Card
You don’t always have to close a card just because it’s not getting used. A few simple changes can make the card easier to manage while helping you keep any potential benefits:
- Add an Authorized User
If it makes sense for your situation, you could consider adding a loved one as an authorized user. This may help a trusted friend, partner, or child start building credit, while you keep the account open, active, and paid on time. Plus, you can still use any of the rewards the card earns. - Downgrade to a Lower-Fee Option
If the annual fee is the main issue, you could look into switching to a card from the same issuer, also known as a product change, with a $0 or lower annual fee. That may let you keep your account history without paying for perks you no longer use. - Use the Card for One Small Recurring Expense
Putting a predictable charge on the card, like an annual subscription or an occasional insurance payment, can help keep the account active. However, you’ll probably want to make sure you’re still tracking it and paying it on time. If you’re keeping the card only for credit-history reasons, enrolling in autopay can help ensure you pay on time and in full. - Freeze the Card if Security Is Your Main Concern
If you want to keep the account open but don’t want the card sitting out there ready for a fraudster to steal, you may be able to freeze it online, in person, or via your issuer’s app. It’s also a good idea to check your credit report from time to time to make sure everything looks right.
- Consider a Balance Transfer Card if You’re Managing Debt
If your bigger concern is simplifying payments on existing balances, a balance transfer card with a limited-time 0% annual percentage rate (APR) (the total cost of annual borrowing) could be worth exploring. These offers can give you room to pay down transferred balances during the promotional period, but it’s important to understand the terms and plan to pay off the entire balance before that period ends.
Frequently Asked Questions
The 2-3-4 rule is a guideline some credit card issuers use to determine how many new credit card applications they’ll approve within a given time frame: 2 in 30 days, 3 in 12 months, and 4 in 24 months.4 But not every issuer uses this rule, so if you’re thinking of canceling an unused card around the same time you’re applying for a new card, it’s worth checking the details before applying and triggering hard inquiries, which can ding your scores, leading to even steeper score drops.
The seven-year rule relates to how long negative credit information, such as missed payments, can remain on your credit report. After seven years, that information generally falls off your credit report.5 But keep in mind that you generally can’t close unused accounts that still carry a balance.
The Takeaway
Closing an unused card isn’t always the best move for your credit: Keeping it open may support a longer credit history and help lower your utilization. If the card feels more annoying than useful, you’ve got options, like downgrading, adding an authorized user, or opting for a balance transfer card that lets you save on interest for a limited time. In any case, making an informed decision about whether to keep the account open can help you become more aware of credit scoring factors and how to navigate them for the best results.
1,2,3 “What Affects Your Credit Scores?,” Experian
4 “Credit card application rules by issuer,” Bankrate
5 “3 big things to know about the 7-year rule for credit card debt,” CBS News
Matt Crespi is a writer, consultant, and social science researcher focused on innovation, policy, and organizational behavior. He earned his PhD in Public Policy and Management at Carnegie Mellon University, where he co-founded the Corporate Startup Lab.
All Credit Intel content is written by freelance authors and commissioned and paid for by American Express.
