Amara Cay Resort

Tranquil coastline escape.

Set along the oceanfront in Islamorada, Amara Cay Resort offers a relaxed gateway to the Upper Keys. Guests enjoy access to water sports, a sunning beach, and a zero-entry pool, along with shared amenities across sister properties in the Islamorada Resort Collection.

Insider Tip

Hop aboard the Rum Rummer water taxi—exclusively for resort guests—to cruise between all three resorts and restaurants in the Islamorada Resort Collection, all while enjoying scenic coastal views.

Where You’re Staying

Coastal-style rooms feature balconies with ocean or bay views, rattan and wood accents, and contemporary furnishings. Suites offer added space with separate living areas and kitchenettes—ideal for extended stays or family travel.

Where to Dine

Savor fresh island flavors at Amara Cay Resort’s dining venues. ReelCatch serves Keys-inspired cuisine for breakfast and dinner, featuring indoor and outdoor seating, daily happy hour, and live music Thursday through Saturday evenings. The poolside Tiki Bar offers classic American fare and tropical cocktails beneath swaying palms. For added convenience, in-room dining is available throughout the day.

Where to Relax

Lounge in a cabana by the zero-entry pool, unwind on the elevated sunning beach, or stay active in the fitness center. Guests also enjoy access to additional relaxation spaces at the resort’s nearby sister property.

What to Do

Play lawn games along the private beach or join a guided eco-tour of local wildlife. Explore rare plants and birds at Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park. Go deep-sea or backcountry fishing in one of the world’s most renowned sportfishing destinations, or snorkel and dive reefs and wrecks with a local captain.

Features

Beachfront

Fitness Center

Pool

Entry-level rooms that accommodate 4+ people

Connecting rooms available