American ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican Express
United StatesChange Country

Should You Get a New Credit Card?

There are times it makes sense to apply for a new credit card – and times it doesn’t. These 10 considerations can help you decide whether now’s a good time for you to apply. 

By Elliot M. Kass | American Express Credit Intel Freelance Contributor

5 Min Read | September 22, 2020 in Cards



There can be several sound financial reasons to apply for a new credit card.

If your income or credit score have gone up, you may be eligible for a better deal on a new credit card than you have on your current card.

But if you’re applying for a big loan – or another change to your financial status is pending – you may be better off delaying a new credit card application.

When should you apply for a new credit card


There are many reasons why you might want another card – or to replace one that you already have. Especially if your credit score has improved since you got your last card, you may qualify for a new one with rewards and benefits that were out of your reach before. 


But there are also some good reasons to delay getting a new card. Here are some key considerations to help you know when it makes sense to go ahead and apply for a new credit card and when it would be better for you to hold off.


When Applying for a New Credit Card May Be a Good Idea

1. Your credit score has improved: If your credit score has gone up since you applied for your current credit card, you may qualify for one with more attractive terms, such as a lower interest rate card, a no annual fee card, or a rewards points and/or cash back card with higher earning rates. 


2. You want to raise your credit score: If your credit file is "thin," an additional card could improve your credit utilization ratio – the portion of your credit you're using relative to your overall credit limit. Because credit utilization counts for 35% in FICO’s scoring model, this might raise your credit score as long as you keep your credit utilization ratio below the suggested 30%. Once you have the new card, though, you still won’t want to close your old card account – that could hurt your credit score by reducing the average age of your credit profile and lowering your overall total credit limit. For more credit score improvement strategies, read “7 Best Ways to Help Build Your Credit.” 


3. Your interest rate is high: A new credit card may net you a lower annual percentage rate (APR). But if this is your goal you may want to try negotiating a reduced rate from your current credit card issuer before applying for a new card, since new card applications generate “hard” credit inquiries that can temporarily lower your credit score. If that doesn’t work out, you may be able to apply for a new 0% intro APR credit card


4. You’re due for a credit limit increase: If it’s been a while since your credit limit has gone up and your current credit card issuer hesitates to increase it, even though your income and credit score have risen over the same period, then you may want to consider looking for a new credit card. Just be sure you can afford to make payments that match your increased spending power. 


5. You’re receiving offers for credit cards with better terms and more rewards: If credit card issuers are sending you offers for credit cards with better terms and more perks than the one you’re currently carrying, then you’re in a good place to take advantage of one of those offers. When companies offer you a new credit card, they have usually pre-qualified you based on your credit history – which could increase your chances of approval. 


6. You want to take advantage of signup bonuses: Many credit cards offer rewards sign-up bonuses to new cardholders who spend a minimum amount of money within a specified initial time period. Especially if you’re planning to make a large purchase, it’s a good idea to take advantage of this. All the more so if the new credit card offers you a lower interest rate than your current card.


When You Might Want to Wait Before Applying for a New Credit Card

1. You’re getting ready to apply for a mortgage, car loan, or another sizeable loan: The reason to delay in this case is that applying for a new credit card can temporarily ding your credit score, which in turn could prevent you from qualifying for the lowest possible rate on a new loan. It’s usually better to first secure the loan at the best rate you can get before shopping for a new credit card. 


2. You’re planning to refinance your mortgage: The reasoning here is the same as No. 1 – it could ding your credit score. For more on mortgage refinancing, read “Guidelines for When and How to Refinance a Home Loan.” 


3. You just lost your job: One of the first things a prospective lender looks at is your source of income. If yours is in jeopardy, it’s typically not a good time to apply for a new credit card. Even if you succeed at getting one, it’s likely that the interest rate will be high and the benefits will be few. For more insight about what to do in this situation, read “Managing Credit Card Debt After a Job Loss.” 


4. You’re carrying large balances on your existing cards: Large balances can lower your credit score and prevent you from getting the best deal on a new credit card. It may be better to pay down some of what you owe first and then apply for the new card that you want.

infographic what is a credit card


The Takeaway

Applying for a new credit card can make good financial sense – especially if you get a better deal than you currently have because your credit score or income has gone up. But timing is everything, so if there’s a pending change to your financial circumstances you might be better off waiting before applying for that new-and-improved credit card.

Elliot Kass

Elliot Kass is a journalist who has covered global business and technology from New York, London, and San Francisco for more than 30 years.


All Credit Intel content is written by freelance authors and commissioned and paid for by American Express. 

The material made available for you on this website, Credit Intel, is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal, tax or financial advice. If you have questions, please consult your own professional legal, tax and financial advisors.