American ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican ExpressAmerican Express
United StatesChange Country

How do Savings Accounts Work in a Zero Interest World?

The effects of zero interest rates from the Federal Reserve mean Americans’ regular savings accounts earn close to zero interest. Here are three higher-interest alternatives. 

By Frances Coppola | American Express Credit Intel Freelance Contributor

7 Min Read | July 17, 2020 in Money

 

At-A-Glance

When the U.S. central bank cuts interest rates to stimulate the economy during downturns, interest rates in standard bank accounts fall close to zero.

To help them comply with federal rules, banks and other finance companies offer higher-interest alternatives that aim to let them hold on to saved funds for longer periods of time.

You can take advantage of those higher rates if you can afford to tie up some of your money for longer periods.

The Federal Reserve – the U.S.’s central bank – cut interest rates to zero in early 2020, and it looks as if they might be staying there for some time. We’ve seen zero interest rates before, they were effectively zero from the Great Recession of 2008 until the Fed started to raise them in 2015.1 If you had a bank savings account during that time, you probably remember your money earning very little interest.

 

Now, we’re back there again: The average interest rate on a standard bank savings or interest-bearing checking account is just above zero.2  If you put your savings into those types of accounts, inflation will reduce the spending power of your money over time (see “Inflation 101: Meaning and Causes”). But there are alternatives that can help soften the effects of zero interest rates on your savings. This article explains:

 

  • Why interest on standard accounts is so low.
  • Why banks and other financial institutions offer alternatives with higher interest.
  • The three main types of higher-yielding alternatives.

 

Why are Interest Rates on Standard Savings Accounts so Low?

To answer this question, you’ll need to know a little bit about the Fed’s rates and how the banking system works.

 

The Fed raises or lowers interest rates to keep the U.S. economy running smoothly so that unemployment stays low and inflation doesn’t get out of control. The interest rate that the Fed directly influences is the Federal Funds Rate, which is the rate at which banks borrow money from each other to make up for funding shortfalls if, for example, a lot of customers withdraw their deposits at once. But banks borrow these funds for very short periods of time, typically overnight. The financial crisis of 2008 showed us that when banks become too reliant on such short-term funding, they can become unstable. As a result, banks are now required to keep larger amounts of “stable funding” – in other words, money that can’t easily be withdrawn.

 

You can withdraw all your money from a standard savings account or interest-bearing checking account without notice. And if you do, the bank might have to borrow overnight from another bank to balance its books. To obtain more stable funding, banks provide a range of products with higher interest rates but which tie up your money in various ways, such as high yield savings accounts and certificates of deposit (CDs). To encourage you to move your savings into these products, banks pay much lower interest on standard savings accounts. Typically, they pay about the same as they would have to pay another bank for overnight funds – which, in a zero-interest-rate world, is pretty much zero.

 

So, one way of increasing the return on your savings is to move them into higher-yielding bank products, if you can afford to tie up the money for a while. There are three basic types:

  • High yield savings accounts.
  • Money market accounts.
  • Certificates of deposit.

 

How do High Yield Savings Accounts Work?

Like standard savings accounts, high yield savings accounts are FDIC insured. This means your money is safe and backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government, provided your balance doesn’t exceed the FDIC limit of $250,000. But the interest rates on high yield savings accounts are far higher than on standard accounts. In May 2020, the annual compound interest rate, or Annual Percentage Yield (APY), on high-yield savings accounts was as much as 1.5%, compared with an average of 0.06% on standard accounts.  For more about APY, see “The Differences Between APR, APY, and Interest Rates.

 

However, higher APYs on savings accounts come with strings attached. You may have to make a minimum deposit to open the account, such as $500 or $1,000. You might have to agree to pay an amount, like $100, into the account monthly. And if the balance on your account drops too low, the interest rate could fall sharply, or you might have to close the account. Additionally, there could be annual or monthly service charges. It’s worth comparing the APYs, conditions, and charges on different high yield savings accounts to see what works best for you.

 

Although high yield savings accounts offer much higher interest rates than standard accounts, they are not immune from Fed interest rate changes. High yield savings account APYs have fallen since the Fed cut rates to zero,3 and they could fall more if the Fed were to introduce negative interest rates. However, they would likely rise if the Fed raised rates.

 

 

Many high yield savings accounts come with online tools that you can use to move money from your high-yield account into your checking account for spending purposes. Additionally, you may be able to use ATMs, and some banks provide checks or a debit card. However, high yield savings accounts aren’t intended for everyday spending. You can deposit money as often as you like, but Fed regulations limit withdrawals from the account to six per month.4

 

Comparison of Selected Savings Accounts

  Standard savings account High yield savings account Money market account CDs
Interest rate Lowest – zero or close Higher than standard accounts Usually higher than HYSAs Usually highest of these accounts
Affected by Fed interest rate changes Yes Yes Yes No
Minimum deposit required Usually none Usually low or up to you Usually high (or fees charged) High
Minimum monthly contribution required No Sometimes No No
Minimum balance required No Low Usually high Same as minimum deposit
Withdrawals Unlimited Maximum 6 per month Maximum 6 per month
Penalty charge for early withdrawals
Can use ATMs, electronic transfers and checks Yes Sometimes Yes No
Fees and charges Low or none Low or none High, unless balance is large None, except for early withdrawals

 

How do Money Market Accounts Work?

Money market accounts are a special type of savings account intended for large amounts of money. The money in them is invested in securities such as U.S. Treasury bonds. They typically offer interest rates above those on high yield savings accounts, but lower than CD rates. There is usually a minimum balance, which can be as high as $2,500 – the interest rate can fall sharply if the balance drops below the minimum. As with high yield accounts, the interest rate can change, so if the Fed cuts rates, the interest rate on your money market account could fall.

 

Money market accounts offer similar facilities to high yield accounts. Money can be deposited or withdrawn at any time using online transfer or via ATMs, and some accounts have checks or debit cards. As with high yield accounts, the number of withdrawals per month is restricted by law to no more than six. There may also be maintenance charges.

 

Despite their name, money market accounts are banking products, and therefore benefit from full FDIC insurance up to a limit of $250,000. In this respect they differ from Money Market Mutual Funds (MMMFs), which don’t have FDIC insurance. As MMMFs are also sold by banks as investment products, it’s important to check the terms and conditions carefully to ensure you are buying an FDIC-insured money market account.5

 

How do Certificates of Deposit (CDs) Work?

If you know you won’t need to withdraw your money for some time, you could opt for a CD.

 

You can buy CDs with maturities ranging from one month to five years. CDs typically offer higher interest rates than high yield savings accounts, and the interest rate on a CD typically rises with the maturity: a one-month CD might pay close to zero, but a five-year CD would offer considerably more. In May 2020, some five-year CDs were paying over 2% APY.

 

Importantly, the interest rate on a CD is fixed, which could be helpful if zero interest rates became negative rates, as has already happened in Europe and Japan. However, if interest rates rise, it might be difficult to take advantage of them because there is typically a penalty for withdrawing money from a CD before its maturity date, which could wipe out the benefit of moving the money to a higher interest account. CDs typically have a minimum investment amount, and some also have a maximum. And unlike high yield savings accounts, CDs won’t offer checks, debit cards, online transfers, or ATM access.

 

Like other bank savings products, CDs benefit from FDIC insurance up to a limit of $250,000 per customer in any one bank.   

 

The Takeaway

In today’s world of zero interest rates, earning returns on your savings can be challenging. However, there are fully insured savings products which deliver returns well above the near-zero of standard savings and interest-bearing checking account. But to benefit from higher rates, you need to be willing to sacrifice some degree of access to your money. The greater the sacrifice, the more you can earn – but the higher risk may be that you lose out if interest rates rise while all your savings are in standard savings accounts. Many people opt for a mixture of standard savings, high-yield, or money market accounts with easy access, and CDs that tie their money up but earn more.

Frances Coppola

Frances Coppola spent 17 years in the financial services industry before becoming a noted writer and speaker on banking, finance, and economics. Her work appears in the Financial Times, Forbes, and a range of financial industry and other publications.

 

All Credit Intel content is written by freelance authors and commissioned and paid for by American Express. 

The material made available for you on this website, Credit Intel, is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal, tax or financial advice. If you have questions, please consult your own professional legal, tax and financial advisors.